FORT SCOTT — Bourbon County now pays $925 a month toward employee-only health coverage and $1,700 for each of the other coverage tiers, $1,023,900 a year in all by Commissioner Mika Milburn-Kee’s figures in the meeting packet. At a Nov. 16 work session, alongside an employee committee’s percentage scenarios, commissioners heard two other ideas for changing that.
Milburn-Kee’s proposal, in the meeting packet, would give all 78 covered employees the same monthly contribution toward the plan of their choice. Assuming all 78 take part for the full year and the full contribution is spent on premiums or eligible HSA deposits, her packet puts the yearly cost at $1,029,600 at $1,100 a month, $1,123,200 at $1,200 and $1,216,800 at $1,300. Each of those monthly contributions is more than the $925 now paid for the 61 employees on employee-only coverage, and less than the $1,700 now paid for the 17 who cover a spouse or children.
Bryan Murphy, who advises the sheriff’s office, suggested instead raising both of the county’s current contributions by 10%. “Everybody wins. Not winners and losers,” he said. Under a flat amount, he said, single employees gain the most. He said a 10% raise would cost only about $3,000 more than a flat amount, and later put the difference at roughly $3,090. Murphy used the $1,300 option as his example, and called his figures “just numbers out of my head.” His estimate was not checked against the packet’s totals during the session.
Milburn-Kee answered that some employees on employee-only coverage, whose spouse carries the children’s insurance, may also feel like losers. Murphy said employees who cover a spouse or children don’t really get a bigger benefit, because they face higher out-of-pocket costs. “You’re comparing apples and grapefruits,” he said. Commissioner David Beerbower said several employees told him they would have liked family coverage but could not afford their share of the premium. “They ended up choosing between their spouse and their child on who they wanted to bring to that plan,” he said of a couple he talked with. Broker Don Doherty listed enrollment as 61 employees with employee-only coverage, five with employee and spouse and 12 with employee and children. No one is on family coverage, Beerbower said.
Near the end of the session, Milburn-Kee said of her equal-contribution proposal, “It doesn’t sound like it has support of the board, though.” “If we decide to go defined contribution, which would be my strong inclination, the goal for Monday is to say what’s the defined contribution for each plan,” Chairman Gregg Motley said. No votes were taken at the work session. On Monday, Nov. 23, commissioners plan to decide whether the county pays a percentage of each premium or a fixed dollar amount, how much it puts toward each of its four plans, and whether to stay with Blue Cross Blue Shield or move to UnitedHealthcare.
Read the full story on the Nov. 16 work session.