Bourbon County Kansas Work Session

Employee committee’s health plan would add about $500,000, Milburn-Kee says; commissioners to decide Nov. 23

FORT SCOTT — A committee of county employees brought Bourbon County commissioners scenarios Monday in which the county would pay 85% to 95% of employees’ health insurance premiums, figures Commissioner Mika Milburn-Kee said would add about half a million dollars to what the county spends now. The county’s HR consultant, Millie Lipscomb, called them starting points, not a final recommendation.

The proposal came at a work session on the county’s 2027 health insurance renewal, where no votes were taken. Chairman Gregg Motley said commissioners would come back next Monday, Nov. 23, to decide three things: whether the county pays a percentage of each premium or a fixed dollar amount, how much it puts toward each of the four plans it offers, and whether to stay with Blue Cross Blue Shield or move to United Healthcare.

“If we decide to go defined contribution, which would be my strong inclination, the goal for Monday is to say what’s the defined contribution for each plan,” Motley said near the end of the session.

Motley presided, with Commissioners David Beerbower, Joe Allen and Milburn-Kee. Commissioner Samuel Tran arrived 30 minutes into the session.

Revised rates

Benefits broker Don Doherty and his colleague Jeremy Bowman said the only change since the Nov. 9 meeting was a 2% reduction from Blue Cross, which they received a few hours before the work session. Blue Cross had first put its renewal at about 14.71% more than this year.

For employee-only coverage, Doherty gave these monthly premiums:

  • Plan A, the current Blue Cross plan with a $1,000 deductible, would go from $1,066.33 to $1,199.66. The comparable UnitedHealthcare plan is $1,182.36.
  • Plan B, Blue Cross’s $2,500-deductible plan, would go from $974.79 to $1,105.53. UnitedHealthcare’s is $1,095.36. Doherty first gave the Blue Cross plan’s out-of-pocket maximum as $4,500; Beerbower noted that with co-pays it reaches $6,350, against $6,000 for UnitedHealthcare’s, and Doherty agreed.
  • Plan C, a Blue Cross health savings account plan with a $3,400 deductible, would go from $972.54 to $1,099.88. UnitedHealthcare’s $4,000-deductible plan is $921.60.
  • Plan D, Blue Cross’s $6,350-deductible HSA plan, would go from $847.01 to $971.87. UnitedHealthcare’s is $784.01.
  • Plans C and D both pay 100% once the deductible is met.

By those dollar figures, the Blue Cross increases run from about 12.5% to 14.7%; Doherty put the Plan D increase at 15.24%.

Milburn-Kee said she wanted insurance documents sent to the full commission as soon as anyone else gets them. “Ultimately the commission is the ones that approve,” she said. Bowman said the brokers had sent figures on Friday to HR consultant Millie Lipscomb, who had asked for numbers for the committee, and Motley asked that anything sent to the committee be copied to the whole commission.

Doherty listed enrollment as 61 employees with employee-only coverage, five with employee and spouse, and 12 with employee and children. No one is currently on family coverage, according to the figures in the meeting packet. The county now puts a flat $925 a month toward employee-only coverage and $1,700 toward each of the other tiers, Bowman and Doherty said. Beerbower said several employees told him they would have liked family coverage but could not afford their share of the premium, and that some chose to cover their children rather than their spouse.

At Milburn-Kee’s request, Doherty explained why he recommends a fixed dollar contribution over a percentage of the premium. A defined contribution, he said, lets the county decide each year how much of a rate increase to absorb, while a percentage rises automatically with the rates. If the county pays a high share of family coverage, he said, families expecting large medical bills may move onto the county plan. He also said that if the county made the plan “too good” it may pick up more healthy people and more good employees, but it may also pick up more “high-risk employees.”  Milburn-Kee, recalling his advice last year, called that “a budget buster.”

Asked by Motley how the county compares, Doherty and Christy Mitchell of Blue Cross said most employers contribute mainly toward the employee. Doherty said the county’s $1,700 “is a good amount, more than most employers in southeast Kansas or Fort Scott are contributing towards an employee spouse,” or toward employees’ children. “What you’re doing is generous.” He said that as a starting point the county could raise its contribution enough to cover half of the increase, with employees covering the other half.

The committee’s plan

Lipscomb said she and the committee members met for more than six hours preparing for the commission work session, that the department heads talked with their employees, and that she had met with employees twice. She presented its work as “starting points,” not recommendations to adopt as written. “None of this is edicts,” she said.

The first scenario had the county paying 95% of employee-only premiums and 85% of the premiums for the other tiers; Lipscomb said she also ran employee-only coverage at 90%. She said she held the sheet back until the work session because “this isn’t something that we’re saying, here’s our suggestion, go with it. This is our discussion synopsis.” Lipscomb said employee-only coverage “used to be at 100%.”

“Our recommendation was the UHC plan,” she said, because one Blue Cross option pays 60% of costs after the deductible rather than 80%, which she said “scared us a little bit.”

“I did not consider this a threat. I considered it a fact,” she said. “Three or four employees told me if things can’t get better, I can’t afford to stay working there.”

Lipscomb said their work is based on approximately $1.4 million budgeted for health insurance in 2027. Milburn-Kee said she had talked with Matt Lawn of Baker Tiller, the county’s accounting firm, who told her that the $1.4 million also covered vision and dental. Near the end of the session, she said the county now pays $1,023,900 a year for health insurance alone, and that the committee’s percentages would bring that to about $1,528,000. “But we cannot blow through the budget,” Motley responded.

Milburn-Kee  told Lipscomb that she had used the wrong percentages for this year. “Why are you being confrontational?” Lipscomb asked. “I’m not. I just want to make sure that you’re using accurate information,” Milburn-Kee said. She said the county’s contributions currently cover 87% of the employee-only premium, 74% for employee and spouse, 79% for employee and children and 49% for family coverage. Lipscomb said she had worked from a copy of an email from a year ago because she does not have access to the current rates.

EMS Director Teri Hulsey, a committee member, said the sheet explaining the committee’s recommendation “wasn’t being withheld as a secret or anything,” but was something the committee wanted to present to commissioners that night for discussion.

Davidson and Milburn-Kee

Undersheriff Kevin Davidson, whom Lipscomb invited to speak, said he was speaking for his employees. Addressing his understanding of Milburn-Kee’s preference for the HSA plan he said, “My employees, where they’re at is we haven’t been getting raises. Yes, you guys approved those raises. But we can’t afford to make it the way it is, let alone to take more money to put in an HSA plan.” His employees, he said, are telling him that if the plans go to HSAs, “I got to pay the electricity. I got to put food on the table. I can’t afford to take any more out of our checks.”

“I think you misunderstood. I wasn’t high on HSA. I was high on employee choice, employee equity, and all the employees getting the same contribution,” Milburn-Kee said. Her proposal, included in the meeting packet, would give every employee the same county contribution, with $1,100, $1,200 and $1,300 a month as options, toward whatever plan they choose, with any amount left after the premium going to an employee’s health savings account where that is allowed. By the packet’s figures, the three options would cost the county $1,029,600, $1,123,200 or $1,216,800 a year, compared with $1,023,900 now, assuming all 78 enrolled employees take part. Employees covering a spouse or children, who now get $1,700, would get the same $1,100 to $1,300 as everyone else. She asked Davidson whether he had read it. “I have not,” he said.

Davidson then turned to Milburn-Kee’s comments at the regular meeting just before the work session, where she had questioned how the committee was formed. “To come against the committee that was put together to help voice our say in this, I found it pretty, frankly, disrespectful,” he said.

Milburn-Kee said a resolution was drafted in 2025 to create a benefits committee, but it wasn’t used to form the current committee and should have been repealed first. Davidson asked whether the commission did not want to hear from employees. “So you’ll listen if it’s done the commissioner’s way,” he said. “That’s incorrect,” Milburn-Kee said. “I’m saying if you wanted to change it, you should change it through the policy that it was written.” Davidson agreed to disagree.

Bryan Murphy, advisor to the sheriff’s office, said raising the county’s current contributions by 10% would come out within roughly $3,090 of a flat contribution, and would help every tier instead of creating “winners and losers.” Murphy used the $1,300 option as his example, which the packet puts at $1,216,800. He said employees who cover a spouse or children also face higher out-of-pocket costs, so comparing them with single employees is “comparing apples and grapefruits.”

Milburn-Kee answered that some employees on employee-only coverage have a spouse who carries their children on another plan, and may “feel like losers because they’re getting $10,000 contributed towards them,” compared with about $20,000 if they took employee-plus coverage.

Hulsey said her employees also leaned toward United Healthcare and were thankful for the 5% raise commissioners approved, but that the insurance increase was a worry without “a considerable contribution” from the county. County Clerk Ann Clarkson said United Healthcare’s network includes some local providers that Blue Cross’s does not. Mitchell answered that Blue Cross has 100% of the hospitals and 98% of providers in Kansas, and that IM Rehab is the only provider she knows of that United Healthcare has and Blue Cross does not. She said employees who switched would “probably lose other providers in UHC, although you would gain that one,” and that the 60-40 difference from the 80-20 rarely matters because members usually reach their out-of-pocket maximum.

Next steps

Beerbower asked the brokers to compare the committee’s plan with what they had presented, and asked that Matt Lawn of Baker Tilly, the county’s financial adviser, check how it fits the budget before commissioners decide. He said employees look at five things in a health plan: the payroll deduction, the deductible, the out-of-pocket maximum, the provider network, and prescription costs. In his own comparison, he said, “the lowest increase while retaining similar benefits was on the Blue Cross Blue Shield.” He said the 5% raise does not cover what employees face from the higher premiums. “If you’re going to retain your employees, especially the ones that are skilled, I mean, you’ve got to take care of them,” he said.

Beerbower also said that, as he understood the claims figures, the spouses and children on the plan had the lowest claims in the group. “I’d hate to sure cut them out and lose them employees to somebody else,” he said.

Allen said he had stopped by Bowman’s office that day with questions about the plans. “We need to hear from Matt, for sure, and see where this is going to fit in the budget,” he said.

Milburn-Kee said her equal-contribution proposal “doesn’t sound like it has support of the board.” She said she had taken out an earlier provision for a $2 premium for employees not on the county plan after Doherty told her the insurer would likely cancel the county.

Lipscomb said she would send commissioners a list of the other committees she has been asked to form and their members, and suggested a work session on how to set them up.

Last week’s discussion of the renewal is here, and the agenda for Monday’s meeting is here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *