Employee committee’s insurance scenarios are “starting points,” HR consultant tells commissioners

FORT SCOTT — A committee of Bourbon County employees brought commissioners scenarios on Nov. 16 in which the county would pay 95% or 90% of employee-only health insurance premiums and 85% of the premiums for the other coverage tiers. HR consultant Millie Lipscomb, who presented them, said the percentages were starting points, not a final proposal. “None of this is edicts,” she said.

Lipscomb said the committee met for about six to six and a half hours and worked from about $1.4 million budgeted for health insurance in 2027. She said she did not know how many employees were in each plan, and called the figures “general numbers to kind of use as borders to operate within.” Commissioner Mika Milburn-Kee said she had talked with Matt Lawn of Baker Tilly, the county’s financial adviser, and that the $1.4 million also covered vision and dental. She said the committee “used the whole budget for just health with no wiggle room.”

Milburn-Kee said the county now pays $1,023,900 a year for health insurance alone, and that the committee’s percentages would bring that to about $1,528,000. “But we cannot blow through the budget,” Chairman Gregg Motley said.

“Our recommendation was the UHC plan,” Lipscomb said, because the 60-40 split in one Blue Cross option “scared us a little bit.” That plan pays 60% of costs after the deductible instead of 80%. Otherwise, she said, the two plans were “so close together.” Christy Mitchell of Blue Cross said later that the 60-40 split rarely matters and that Blue Cross could quote an 80-20 version. Lipscomb also asked commissioners to keep what employees pay for employee-only coverage low, and said three or four employees had told her they could not afford to keep working for the county if things don’t get better. “I did not consider this a threat. I considered it a fact,” she said.

Commissioner David Beerbower asked the brokers to compare the committee’s plan with what they had presented, and asked Lawn to check how it fits the budget, before commissioners decide. Commissioner Joe Allen said he also wanted to hear from Lawn. No votes were taken at the work session. On Monday, Nov. 23, commissioners plan to decide whether the county pays a percentage of each premium or a fixed dollar amount, how much it puts toward each of its four plans, and whether to stay with Blue Cross Blue Shield or move to UnitedHealthcare.

Read the full story on the Nov. 16 work session.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *